By striking a deal with Israel Nasrallah makes another step towards legitimization
5 Star
Share This Post
Elijah , Tel-Aviv: Jul 1 2008
Made Popular Jul 1 2008

hnasrallah_bjo9s_17717

The day before yesterday (Sunday, June 29) Israeli cabinet approved an unusual deal: the bodies of two Israeli soldiers in exchange for Samir Kuntar and several other Lebanese Hezbollah related terrorists.

Even more unusual is the timing. There are no apparent reasons for the deal; Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah leader, has always regarded the Israeli soldiers (deemed alive until recently) as trumps that would keep Israel in check — for years — at the expense of the hostages’ families emotional state. Some relatives of the Israeli captives have addressed Nasrallah directly via various media, pleading to release their loved ones and, when desperate, calling him a cruel tormentor.

Tormentor or not, Nasrallah publicly admitted that he is in no hurry, evidently relishing the opportunity to push Israel’s buttons (his son was a Hezbollah fighter killed by IDF), stating that it is up to Israel to convince him that an exchange had to take place. His decision to give in and strike a deal with the Jewish state was prompted by latest national rather than international goings on.

Hezbollah seeks to establish itself as a legitimate political player in Lebanon. What the organization’s leader gave in to was not the heartfelt pleas but his own lust for power. He wants to rule Lebanon and, while the latest upheavals are to his advantage, he needs to cement his status as an all-round political figure — and not just the head of a militant terrorist group.

His role model is no other than Yasser Arafat, who, though once ostracized for being a bloody murderer, reinvented himself as the chairman of the Palestinian authority and eventually received the Nobel Peace Prize. As outrageous as this may sound, Nasrallah may be just as good a candidate. All it takes is a (seemingly) honest transformation from a blood thirsty terrorist to a peace loving negotiator.

To everybody’s relief, Nasrallah finally displays a real human weakness.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
1 Stars
R.M.Paulraj
Bangalore, India
The move by any extremist leader towards becoming a moderate political negotiator deserves appreciation and recognition by all. It is the best way to defeat terrorism.
1 Stars
I agree, R.M.

I think the best way to defeat terrorists is to make them ”soft” and eventually convince them to abandon their violent ways, even if that means political concessions. At least these will be without bloodletting.
1 Stars
R.M.Paulraj
Bangalore, India
I feel that there is a need for an apolitical organization outside the UN, consisting of people like us, to engage in dialogues with factions of extremist organizations that could be encouraged to open up for a process of political conciliation aimed at cooperation. Presently there is a void in this space, and things are left to government bodies.
1 Stars
This seems like a very good idea.

However, the task you described sounds very daunting. For instance, many governments have laws that prevent private individuals (or even organizations like the one you have in mind) from contacting extremists. Those who do risk trial or at least ostracism. If officials eventually decide to overlook the laws, they want to be the ones breaking it, in hope of political gain.

In the Middle East such endeavors are almost surely bound to be viewed as naive, arrogant and out of touch. There must be some other incentive that would make the talks more pragmatic — the idealistic liberal enlightened approach is just too much for the traditionalist region — like a business venture. I think that is why Germany’s low and mid rank officials are successful in negotiating between Israel and Lebanon: they have strong business connections and interests in Iran and among Shiite population.
1 Stars
R.M.Paulraj
Bangalore, India
True. Laws do prevent contacts between terrorists and ordinary citizens. These laws are a necessity too, for obvious reasons. But, people who have interests in the concerned countries - like the Germans who worked between Israel and Lebanon - can make a beginning in this direction.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
That said, I have very little knowledge about how things might work in India, where I understand there are tensions between Muslim and Hindu populations.
1 Stars
R.M.Paulraj
Bangalore, India
Terrorists are usually inaccessible to others, in whichever country they are. This is the case in India as well. But some terrorist organizations, both in India and elsewhere in the world, have a political wing or front that serves as an interface between them and the outside world.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Well done on your article Elijah! I agree it is unusual timing, but eventually the time must come where one of the sides has to cede to each others wishes/demands/whatever you would like to call it...

I only wish that this swap goes as ”smoothly” as they say it will.
Add your Comment